The HOA’s New Cost Schedule for Records Requests Raises Transparency Questions

At the September 23, 2025 meeting, the board adopted a new Member Access to Records and Cost Schedule, setting fees of $30 per hour for staff time and up to 30¢ per page for copies of HOA records requested by homeowners.

Virginia law allows associations to recover reasonable costs for producing records, and it requires boards to adopt a cost schedule before charging anything. So adopting a schedule was appropriate.

The question isn’t whether a schedule was needed.
It’s what the board adopted, when it adopted it, and how it was presented.


What the Board Approved

Under the new policy:

  • Staff time is billed at $30 per hour
  • Copies may cost up to 30¢ per page

Those rates are notably higher than what many associations charge for routine administrative work.

To put this in practical terms: a homeowner requesting a simple, three-page contract could be billed for a full hour of staff time plus copying costs — over $30 for a basic records request.

That raises a fair question about what “reasonable” is supposed to mean.


Timing Matters

This is a new association with:

  • a limited number of records
  • very few records requests
  • no demonstrated backlog or administrative strain

Yet the board chose to adopt an aggressive cost schedule now, without explaining what problem it was intended to solve.

When policies that restrict access to information are adopted without a clear operational need, homeowners are justified in asking why.


Confusion About “FOIA”

During the discussion, references were made to “FOIA.”

That was puzzling.

FOIA does not apply to HOAs. Only homeowners are entitled to association records. Records requests cannot come from the general public.

Raising FOIA in this context suggests either a misunderstanding of the law or an attempt to frame records access as a burden that it is not.


What Was Missing From the Discussion

Notably absent from the board’s explanation was basic information that would help homeowners evaluate the decision, such as:

  • how many records requests the HOA has actually received
  • how much staff time those requests have required
  • whether existing processes were insufficient

Without that context, homeowners were asked to accept a new policy without understanding its necessity.


Lack of Advance Notice

Once again, the full policy was not provided to homeowners in advance of the meeting.

The agenda was distributed, and there was ample opportunity to include the proposed cost schedule for review. Instead, homeowners were presented with the policy during the meeting itself.

Brief explanations are not a substitute for advance notice. Policies affecting access to information deserve time for review and discussion.


Why This Raises Transparency Concerns

The board has not eliminated access to records.

But increasing costs, providing little notice, and offering limited explanation all have the same effect: making information harder to obtain.

Transparency is not measured by whether access technically exists.
It’s measured by whether access is practical, fair, and encouraged.

When barriers quietly increase, trust erodes — even if the door isn’t formally closed.


Bottom Line

Adopting a records-access policy should make the process clearer and more predictable for homeowners.

This one does the opposite.

And that’s why it deserves closer scrutiny.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments