When Homeowner Oversight Becomes a Personal Fight

What I witnessed at last Tuesday’s Board meeting was unlike anything I have seen in the hundreds of Board meetings I have attended over the years.

Board President Denney devoted a substantial portion of his report to criticizing me for submitting records requests. These were requests for ordinary Association records of the kind typically maintained and made available to homeowners—not demands for specially created reports or unusual disclosures. We’re talking about things like income statements, landscaping invoices, and snow removal contracts.

Denney portrayed these requests as creating a considerable workload for the Association and holding me responsible for substantial legal expenses. But nine requests for ordinary Association records hardly demonstrate the extraordinary workload he described. Many of these records already exist in electronic form and can be retrieved and provided with just a few mouse clicks. This is hardly the kind of work that should consume a substantial amount of management or Board time. And while the Association may have incurred legal expenses, that does not establish that I caused them. The decision to involve the attorney was the Board’s, and the responsibility for those decisions rests with the Board.

If Denney wants to have an honest discussion about records requests, that’s fine. There’s nothing wrong with discussing how requests are handled, what they cost, or whether procedures can be improved. But that’s not what happened here. This was a concerted effort to present a one-sided and inaccurate picture of my records requests, diminish me in the eyes of other homeowners, and discourage them from turning to this blog for independent oversight of the Board.

When Board members use their positions to criticize a homeowner publicly, they have a built-in advantage. Many residents naturally give considerable weight to what their Board says, and not everyone has the time or inclination to investigate the issues for themselves.

There is also a larger concern here. Denney’s approach to homeowner oversight, records access, and the handling of complaints doesn’t just affect me. It creates unnecessary conflict, exposes the Association to potential legal and financial consequences, and raises serious questions about his judgment as Board President. In trying to discredit a homeowner who is asking questions, he may be creating risks for the very Association he is supposed to serve.

I did interrupt Denney during his speech. I recognize that this was contrary to meeting protocol, but I felt his presentation contained such serious misrepresentations that I needed to fact-check him in real time. I stand by my decision to speak up.

Before getting into Denney’s speech and the Board’s review of my complaint concerning its refusal to provide an architectural change request application, it’s important to understand several events that occurred in the months leading up to the meeting.

Tom Denney
Board President Tom Denney

The Ombudsman Decision

Earlier this year, I filed a complaint with the Virginia Common Interest Community Ombudsman that included two separate complaints against the Association. I wrote about it here. One concerned the Association’s refusal to provide architectural change request applications for several lots. The other concerned its refusal to provide first-notice covenant violation letters. The Ombudsman issued a determination addressing both records disputes and also identified deficiencies in the Association’s handling of homeowner complaints.

The Ombudsman found that the Association acted contrary to Virginia law by refusing to provide the architectural change request applications and ordered the Association to produce the records, subject to any lawful withholding or redactions. The Ombudsman did not order production of the first-notice covenant violation letters, but that should not be mistaken for a finding that the Association lawfully withheld them. That issue remains unresolved. The Ombudsman also identified significant deficiencies in the Association’s complaint-handling process, including a lack of evidence that the Board had actually considered the complaints, and directed the Association to provide training.

The Ombudsman emphasized that responding to member complaints demonstrates “good stewardship” and promotes “transparency and good governance.” His findings also made clear that the Association needed to take its legal obligations and its members’ concerns seriously and handle complaints properly. I believe the decision called for a more constructive approach to homeowner concerns—not an increasingly adversarial one. Instead, Denney’s subsequent remarks and conduct appeared to reflect resentment and defiance rather than a willingness to take the Ombudsman’s findings to heart.



The Board Revises the Member Access to Association Records & Cost Schedule

Shortly after the Ombudsman’s determination, the Board adopted a revised Member Access to Association Records & Cost Schedule. The new policy went beyond establishing procedures and costs for obtaining records. It expressly prohibited members from publishing Association records—or even information contained in those records—on publicly accessible websites and social media platforms. That restriction directly affects the ability of homeowners to share information about Association business through independent websites such as this blog. The policy also required members to agree to its restrictions when submitting a records request.

The policy’s restrictions would soon become central to a dispute over my request for an architectural change request application for the fence installed on Lot 171.



The Lot 171 Records Request and the Board’s Denial

I submitted a records access request using the new form adopted with the revised Member Access to Association Records & Cost Schedule. The request sought the architectural change request application for the fence installed on Lot 171—the same type of record the Ombudsman had previously determined the Association was required to produce.

The new form included restrictions on how homeowners could use and share records they obtained. I added a qualification stating that I reserved my rights under Virginia law. In plain English, I was making clear that I did not agree to any provision of the policy that would restrict rights I have under Virginia law. I did not cross out or alter any part of the form, contrary to what Denney later claimed during the Board’s review of my complaint.

The Board refused to process my records request because I included that qualification.



My Complaint Over the Lot 171 Records Denial

Following the Board’s denial of my request for the architectural change request application for the fence installed on Lot 171, I submitted a written complaint to the Association. The complaint focused on a specific question: Can the Association refuse to process an otherwise qualifying records request unless the homeowner first agrees to a restriction on public dissemination that is not expressly stated in the Virginia Property Owners’ Association Act?

I asked the Board to direct management to process the request and provide the requested records, subject to any lawful redactions, without requiring me to accept the disputed publication restriction. I also asked the Board, if it disagreed, to identify the specific factual and legal grounds for refusing the request and explain how making acceptance of that restriction a condition of access complies with Virginia law. My complaint was not about every possible use or publication of Association records. It was about whether the Association could make acceptance of a disputed restriction a condition of obtaining records in the first place.

The Board considered my complaint toward the end of the meeting.



The Facebook Ads Distributed Before Denney’s Speech

Before Denney’s speech on records requests, he distributed copies of ads from my Facebook campaign promoting this blog for the audience to pass around. The ads used parody to promote the blog. You can see them for yourself below.

Denney characterized the ads as examples of “immature, childish activity” that the Board and management company had to deal with. But what, exactly, did they have to deal with? The ads promoted an independent homeowner blog. They were not Association business, and there is no apparent reason the management company would have needed to take any action concerning them.

Why were these blog advertisements being presented at the meeting at all? They had no apparent connection to the records requests or the other matters Denney discussed immediately afterward. I suppose the audience needed a little warm-up before the main event.


Parody Facebook advertisement showing Denney with Ruppert Landscaping employees and a snow removal contract stamped breached.
Parody advertisement depicting three Winchester Landing Board members wearing crowns, with text criticizing the reduction of the Board from five seats to three and the lack of townhouse and condominium representation.

Denney’s Speech

Now let’s look at Denney’s speech at the meeting, which covered several subjects: the burden he said records requests placed on the Board and management, the legal expenses he attributed to those requests, his personal frustration with me, and his characterization of the Ombudsman’s decision. Rather than summarize those remarks, the following transcript shows what he said. The figures and characterizations are Denney’s claims, not independently verified findings.

I have chosen not to include a video clip of Denney’s speech to protect the privacy of Coventry Group Community Manager Keila’s young daughter, who was present at the meeting and would appear in the recording. A written transcript is provided instead. A video clip later in this post shows the Board’s review of my complaint, but Keila’s daughter is outside the frame.


Transcript of Denney’s speech

I’m going to pass around some pictures. I would like for you to look at them, pass them around to your people sitting around you. Take a look, pass them around.

These pictures are an example of immature, childish activity that this board and our management company has to deal with from Mr. David Gillette.

So I do want to say that every homeowner has the right to ask for documentation from us. They have the right to look at the numbers.

They have a right to complain to the state about us. And we’re not saying against that. But there’s a difference between exercising that right and creating an ongoing situation that just takes extraordinary time and stress, and it’s just ridiculous. This is an HOA.

Oh, yeah. I forgot to see the picture of the dog. He calls himself the HOA watchdog. Instead of referring to him as Mr. Gillette, you can refer to him as the HOA watchdog.

So the number of e-mails and requests that come in from Gillette are just asinine. It is over and over and over.

I forgot my crown. That’s right. I am the king. Jeez.

It’s ridiculous. The e-mails that come in from him are ridiculous.

It’s my turn. It’s the president’s report, not her turn to speak. They’re ridiculous, folks. They just are over and over. You can oversight me all you want because I’m not doing anything wrong. I’m not doing anything wrong.

So e-mail requests that come in.

No, it’s okay. Listen, I’m going to keep going. I can speak louder.

I’m going to give you some information. For every email that he sends in, right, he sends one email in requesting documentation because he wants to oversee us, to see what we’re doing, what we’re spending, what we’ve done. For every email that he sends in, there’s 30, there’s 15 to 20 additional emails on that. By the time they go to Keila, they go to us, they go to the attorney, they come back from the attorney, they go back to him, he argues them back, each email is 10 to 15 additional emails, in a job that we volunteered for. I still work folks.

So he’s sent about 30 requests in this year. Times 10 to 15, we’re talking 300 to 450 additional emails that this board and our management company has to deal with. And it goes on and on and on and on and on, and they’re ridiculous. You must remember that back in September we sent all of you another records request form. Did everybody remember seeing that. So do you remember seeing one last year? So we had to redo one this year. Why? Because we had to do another one to protect the HOA from Gillette. Because of his actions.

I’m going to give you some more information here. We have had to engage, so yes all HOA’s have an attorney right. You got to. But we have had to engage our attorney on 36 occasions simply because of Gillette. Those numbers are facts. Above and beyond the retainer that we pay our attorney to take care of HOA business, we’ve spent year to date $4,122 additional dollars because of him. That’s your money. That comes out of your $140. It comes out of his own money too which is kind of funny. But it comes out of your money every month.

So let’s put it in perspective. You got 121 homes right that’s the singles and the townhouses and we have 48 condos technically so that number is 169. Out of the 169 dwellings that we have, no one else does this. People might call about a question. The condos might call and say [unintelligible]. This is exhausting. He’s exhausting. We’re volunteers right. We’re volunteers. All of this volunteer job is spent on him. It’s spent on him. I can’t even sometimes [unintelligible].

I’m going to wrap this up real quick. Every day I wake up and I think I’m going to quit this board I’ve had enough. It’s a volunteer job. But I will not quit. I will not give this man, I will not give this man, the honor of quitting. I think at the last meeting I told you what he did to me right? He drove up to my driveway and he says one down two more to go.

Last but not least on this particular subject, I am concerned about our management company. And Keila. Because as much as he says he and Keila are buds, I’m not going to say what they, what I am going to say is I’ve done her [unintelligible]. She has, how many sites total, 9? She has 9, besides us, she has 9. Right, and out of her workday, 80% is dealt with Winchester Landing. We pay this management company $1000 a month. In today’s society $1000 is nothing. Right. Think if I were Coventry I would come back to Winchester Landing and say I need, I need, some money.

I’m here, I’m in my second year, and I’m going into my third year and I’m going to run again. To do everything I can to keep this man [unintelligible]. That’s my speil. I just wanted to let you guys know. I wanted you to see the pictures. The childish, you know, the immature childish stuff. That’s my President’s report. Thank you for letting me scream at you, I’m sorry. But I had to.

This man is costing our association money and lots of heartache. I’m not sure if you know that he has already sued the HOA once along with a board member who was a homeowner. So it’s your money. And when you get sued, when someone files a lawsuit, you have to lawyer up right? You got to, what are you going to do. You have to. We have to. We can’t just say oh well whatever. He lost. He lost that suit.

But now, every time, because he started a lawsuit, our attorney has said, that we need, you know, everything that comes from him is going through legal because we don’t know where it’s going to end up. He did just mention that he sent something to the ombudsman, I don’t know if you guys know who that is. But that’s the state of Virginia. [unintelligible] That’s where contracts are looked at or whatever. And the ombudsman is somebody who looks at complaints from someone like him who sends it down there complaining about the HOA that were doing something wrong. He complained that we didn’t provide him with some documentation. He did two complaints. Or two in one. He won one he lost one. So what we had to give him some documents. Big deal. We don’t care.

He did. The ombudsman said yes you should have gave it to him according to 55122. You know what we said? Whoops, our bad.


Response to Denney’s Speech

The Claim That I Submitted 30 Records Requests

Denney claimed that I had “sent about 30 requests in this year.” That figure is nowhere close to the actual number. My records show the following nine records requests in 2026:

  • January 27: Greatscapes snow removal contract
  • April 13: First-notice covenant violation letters
  • May 13: January, February, and March income statements
  • June 2: Approved fence applications for six lots
  • August 11: April, May, and June income statements
  • August 14: Ruppert Landscaping invoices
  • September 15: December 31, 2025 balance sheet
  • October 15: Approved fence application for Lot 171
  • November 3: July, August, and September income statements and insurance policies

The Claim That Each Request Generates 10 to 15 Emails

Denney claimed that each records request generates 10 to 15 emails. That’s an absurd amount of correspondence to suggest would result from nine requests for ordinary Association records. These are routine documents that the Association should be able to retrieve and provide without turning every request into a major undertaking.

Protecting the HOA—or Limiting Scrutiny?

Denney said the revised records-request form was necessary “to protect the HOA from Gillette because of his actions.” But what harm was he referring to? He offered no explanation. What specific actions had harmed the Association? How does publishing ordinary HOA records on this blog damage the HOA? Simply invoking the need to “protect the HOA” without identifying any actual harm is not an explanation. It sounds more like a justification for restricting access to information than a legitimate reason for doing so.

The Claim That I Cost the HOA $4,122 in Legal Fees

Denney claimed that the Association had engaged its attorney on 36 occasions because of me and attributed $4,122 in legal expenses to my activities. That’s a remarkable amount of legal involvement to attribute to just nine records requests for ordinary Association records. Even more troubling is the implication that the Association’s legal expenses are largely the result of my requests.

The Association’s September 30, 2026 income statement reported $3,876.18 in year-to-date Legal Fees. The attorney handles all sorts of Association business, much of which has nothing to do with me or my records requests. Yet Denney presented these expenses as though they were the consequence of my activities. He provided no breakdown showing what work was performed, which matters it concerned, or how the expenses were attributed to me.

There is another point Denney conveniently overlooks. The Ombudsman’s decision found that the Association had acted contrary to Virginia law by refusing to provide the approved architectural change request applications. It also found that the Association failed to comply with Virginia’s requirements for responding to homeowner complaints. These were not frivolous complaints or unnecessary disputes. They exposed failures in the Association’s handling of records requests and its complaint procedure. The legal expenses associated with defending those decisions are a consequence of the Board’s own actions and decisions. Responsibility for those decisions—and the resulting expense—rests with the Board, not the homeowner who challenged them.

The Board Presidency Is Not a Personal Feud

Denney then made a particularly revealing statement. He said that he thinks about quitting the Board every day, but refuses to give me “the honor of quitting.” That is a remarkable way for a Board President to describe his motivation for continuing to serve.

Serving on the Board is a responsibility to the entire community. It should be about governing the Association and acting in the homeowners’ best interests—not about winning a personal contest with one homeowner. By framing his decision to remain on the Board in terms of me, Denney made this personal conflict impossible to ignore. Homeowner oversight and criticism should not be treated as a personal challenge that a Board President needs to defeat.

Is the Management Company Underpaid?

Denney also expressed concern that Coventry Management may not be receiving enough compensation for its work, claiming that 80% of Keila’s workday is devoted to Winchester Landing while the Association pays Coventry only $1,000 per month. The implication was that my records requests are creating a considerable workload for management. That’s a rather remarkable suggestion given that I’ve submitted only nine requests this year, all for ordinary Association records. Denney provided no supporting information for his 80% figure, nor did he explain how much of Keila’s time was actually spent handling my requests as opposed to the ordinary work of managing the Association. There’s simply no way for homeowners to verify his claim.

There is another troubling aspect to Denney’s remarks. Why would the Board President publicly suggest, in front of the management company, that it is underpaid and should ask the Association for more money? The Board’s responsibility is to protect the financial interests of the Association and its homeowners—not to volunteer the possibility of paying its management company more without any explanation of why an increase is warranted. That is a rather extraordinary position for the person responsible for overseeing the Association’s finances to take.

Does Every Records Request Have to Go Through the Attorney?

Denney claimed that, because of my lawsuit against the HOA and former Board member Guevremont last year, the Association’s attorney advised that everything coming from me should go through legal. How convenient, when homeowners have no way to independently verify this supposed directive. It seems far more likely that Denney is using this dubious claim to shift responsibility for his own poor decisions to involve legal in virtually everything I submit, regardless of whether it actually requires legal attention, onto the attorney. But even if the attorney did make that recommendation, the Board was under no obligation to follow it. The decision to involve legal was ultimately the Board’s, and the resulting expenses are its responsibility—not mine.

The Ombudsman’s Decision: “Whoops, Our Bad”

Denney’s description of the Ombudsman proceedings was equally revealing. He characterized the complaints as something the Association had to deal with, dismissed the fact that it had to provide documents as “no big deal,” and then described the Association’s failure to provide records as “Whoops, our bad.”

I wonder what the ombudsman would think of Denney’s cavalier attitude toward his strongly worded determination finding the HOA, under his leadership, failed to comply with state law. That sounds pretty serious to me.

The Claim That I Lost the Lawsuit

Denney also told homeowners that I lost the lawsuit I filed last year concerning former Board member Guevremont’s fence on Lot 171, which is located within a stormwater easement—a location where the covenants do not permit a fence. I wrote about it here. That characterization leaves out an important distinction. The lawsuit was dismissed at the demurrer stage and did not proceed to trial. The court therefore made no factual finding that the fence complied with the covenants. Although the lawsuit ended, the underlying compliance question was never decided.

To this day, the Association has not addressed the apparent covenant violation involving the fence—a situation that could expose the Association to liability if flooding occurs. I am seeking the architectural change request application for this fence to determine whether it was actually approved and, if so, how the Association approved it despite its location within the stormwater easement.

A Lesson in Maturity from Board President Denney

During his speech, Denney blew a kiss at the camera and, at another point, made a karate-like kicking motion in its direction, while Board member Plavnieks cheered him on. Remember, this is the same Denney who criticized my advertisements as “immature” and “childish.”



The Board’s Review of the Lot 171 Complaint

After Denney finished his speech, the Board took up my complaint concerning the refusal to provide the architectural change request application for the fence installed on Lot 171.

You may be wondering whether the Board followed this same process when I filed my two complaints with the Ombudsman. It didn’t. The Board never formally addressed either complaint in this manner. Here’s what the Ombudsman had to say about that:



Watch the video. You can decide for yourself whether Denney takes the complaint process seriously. At times, he almost gives the impression that he’s being forced to participate.



Transcript of the Board’s Review of the Lot 171 Complaint

I’m going to stand up again because I have to, so that $4,120.50 does not include this latest directions given to us by the attorney yesterday that I have to do tonight, so. Where is it? Where’s my thing? Okay, right here. All right.

On October 15th, Mr. Gillette requested some documentation from the HOA, and this is, the attorney has told me I have to do this, to go through this entire process here. He filled out the documentation, but crossed out the part and said, I will not adhere to the fact that I can’t do what I want with this, i.e. post it publicly, do whatever he does with the pictures or whatever. Based on that, we denied his request to give him the documentation he requested.

What he was requesting was the fence issue, or lack thereof, on lot 171, two years into this. We’re still looking at that, and if you guys want to know, that’s Mike Guevremont’s old house, or still his house, that corner lot there. He’s still harping on that fence.

We didn’t give it to him, all right? So a couple days later, he files an official complaint, which all of you can do, if you don’t like what we’re doing, or we tell you no, or whatever, you have the right to file an official complaint to Coventry, which then goes to the board, and we have to hear what you got to say. So at this point, in the next part of what the attorney has asked me to do, is I have to ask Gillette if he has any additional comments about this particular subject. Not anything else other than the subject of you requesting documents regarding the fence on lot 171.

No. He has no comments. Coventry, do you have any extra, anything you’d like to add? Board, anything you’d like to add on this particular complaint Gillette has made against us? No.

All right. Back in February, the, our attorney, there we go again with that attorney, right? Every time you say attorney, what, it’s $300, $400, right? Cha-ching, cha-ching, cha-ching, he just keeps racking up. I think he charges us, thankfully, in 15-minute increments.

So one email is a 15-minute increment at $400 an hour, do the math. Back in February, our attorney sent Mr. Gillette an email saying, stop posting association documents on your public site, whatever he has. He’s refused to do so and continues to do so.

So thanks to the fact that we created the new records request thing, again saying don’t post it publicly, which he refuses to do, right? He scratched it out. I want these documents, but I’m not following the rules of this, of this records request that, that we wrote and, and there we are. Even if he resubmits the, the records request that he wants for the fence on lot 171, he will not get the final notice to the homeowner, the decision made by the board or the whoever to, that approved the fence, because that is proprietary information to the homeowner and your lot, and that is not something that’s given out.

So that might make you even feel a little bit better. If we tell you, no, you’re not getting a fence because of X, Y, and Z, that’s between management, the board, and you. They don’t get to know that.

You want to share, you can share, but they don’t get to know that, so. So based off the discussion on all this, I have to make another motion, and I’m reading this verbatim from legal. Regarding the complaint submitted by Mr. Gillette involving the association’s not providing requested records because he altered the association’s required records access form, I move that the board’s final determination is that Gillette’s 1015 records request was properly rejected because of Gillette’s altered language on the request form, which indicates his refusal to conform that the records would be used only for proper purposes rather than being published to the general public.

Furthermore, that management will then finalize and send Mr. Gillette the required notice of final determination in consultation with our association’s attorney. I need a second. Second.

All in favor? Aye. Passed. Okay.


Response to Board’s Review of the Lot 171 Complaint

The Attorney Fees—Again

Denney returned to the Association’s legal expenses before the Board even considered the substance of my complaint, making cash register sounds this time. It was the same message he had delivered in his speech: legal expenses were accumulating, and I was being held responsible. But repeating that argument did nothing to answer the question before the Board: had the Association properly rejected my records request? Instead of addressing that question, Denney was simply playing the blame game again.

Why Make it Personal?

Denney chose to personalize the explanation as to why the Board refused to process my records request when a straightforward account of the Board’s decision would have been sufficient.

Something like this.

On October 15th, Mr. Gillette requested documentation from the Association. Under the Association’s records-access policy, he was asked to complete the required form. He submitted the form but crossed out the provision requiring him to agree to the policy’s restriction on publicly sharing the documents. Because he did not agree to that provision, the Association denied his request.

Why the Association Rejected the Request

Denney explained that the Association rejected my October 15 request because I crossed out the form language restricting public posting of records and reserved my rights under Virginia law. That description was inaccurate, as I explained above. I did not cross out or alter any of the form language. I simply added a qualification making clear that I did not agree to any policy restriction that would limit rights afforded to me under Virginia law.

My complaint, however, raised a narrower question: could the Association make acceptance of that publication restriction a condition of access when the restriction was not expressly stated in the Virginia Property Owners’ Association Act? The Board needed to address that question, but it did not.

The underlying issue is straightforward: the Board cannot use a policy to take away or restrict rights that homeowners have under Virginia law. The Board may adopt reasonable procedures for administering records requests, but those procedures must be consistent with the law. My complaint alleged that the Association crossed that line by making agreement to its publication restriction a condition of access to records. The question was not whether the Board could adopt a records policy. It was whether this particular restriction was lawful.

Bringing the Homeowner Into It

Denney identified lot 171 as former board member Guevremont’s fence and remarked, “He’s still harping on that fence.” The homeowner’s identity had no apparent relevance to the complaint. The issue before the Board was whether the Association could refuse to provide an architectural change request application unless a homeowner agreed to the policy’s publication restriction. Identifying the homeowner and characterizing my effort to obtain the record as “harping” did nothing to answer that question. It shifted the discussion away from the Association’s records-access obligations and toward a personal characterization of my conduct.

The February Cease-and-Desist Letter

Denney stated that the HOA attorney sent me a cease-and-desist letter last February demanding that I stop posting Association documents on this website, but that I refused and continued doing so.

What Denney omitted is that I responded in writing, explaining why I disputed the Association’s legal position and declining to comply with the demand.

The Association did not pursue the threatened legal action, and no court has determined that my publication of Association records was unlawful. The attorney’s letter represents a disputed legal position, not a legal determination establishing the Association’s authority to impose a publication restriction as a condition of records access.

The Claim That the Approval Decision Is Proprietary

Denney said that even if I submitted the records request again, the Association would not provide the final notice or the decision approving the fence on Lot 171 because he considered that information proprietary to the homeowner.

But an architectural change request approval is an Association decision made under the governing documents. Other homeowners have a legitimate interest in understanding how those documents are interpreted and applied, particularly when questions of consistent enforcement arise. Calling the decision private does not, by itself, establish a legal basis for withholding the record. This does not mean every detail of a homeowner’s application must be disclosed; personal information and legitimately confidential material can be redacted. The question is why the Association would withhold the actual decision and the reasons supporting it, even after appropriate redactions.

That statement deserves particular attention in light of the Ombudsman’s earlier determination. In that matter, the Ombudsman found that architectural change request applications were not among the records that could be withheld under the statutory exception relied upon by the Association, found that the Association had acted contrary to Virginia law, and ordered the Association to produce the requested applications, subject only to withholding or redaction permitted by law.

The approval or decision page is not some unrelated document. It is part of the architectural change request application and is central to understanding the outcome of the application. The Association cannot establish that it may withhold that information merely by labeling it proprietary. If it believes a particular portion is legally protected, it should identify the specific legal basis for withholding or redacting it. The Board’s position appears to contemplate providing, at most, part of the architectural change request application while withholding the information that establishes the actual approval. That would defeat an important part of the purpose of requesting an approved architectural change request application in the first place.

The Board’s Final Determination

Denney then read a proposed motion that he said came verbatim from the Association’s attorney. The motion declared that the request had been properly rejected because I altered the form and refused to agree that the records would be used only for proper purposes rather than published to the general public. It also directed management to prepare and send me a Notice of Final Determination in consultation with the attorney. The motion was seconded and passed by the Board.

On November 12, I received the HOA’s Notice of Final Determination. The Board upheld its rejection of my records request because I refused to accept the restriction on public disclosure.



Denney Has Become a Risk to the Association

What concerns me most is that Denney appears to have taken my records requests and oversight activities far too personally. His repeated public criticism, his focus on the expense and inconvenience he attributes to me, and his statement that he would not give me the “honor of quitting” suggest that this has become more than a disagreement over how the Association should be managed. The issue seems to have become personal. That raises a legitimate question about whether his personal feelings are affecting his judgment as President. That is the risk I am talking about.

A Board President is entitled to disagree with homeowners, defend Board decisions, and express frustration when dealing with difficult issues. But he also has a responsibility to exercise sound judgment, respect the Association’s legal obligations, and act in the interests of the entire community—not allow personal grievances to influence how he performs that role.

The consequences do not fall on Denney alone. Questionable policies, unnecessary attorney involvement, decisions that disregard homeowners’ rights, and public statements that undermine confidence in the Board can expose the Association to legal and financial costs. Ultimately, those costs and consequences belong to the homeowners.

The concern is not that Denney dislikes being challenged. It is that his reaction to being challenged may be compromising his judgment and exposing the Association to unnecessary risk.

The Board has shown no reluctance to turn to Chadwick for legal advice whenever questions arise about my records requests and oversight activities. Perhaps it is time for the Board to ask Chadwick a different question: What risks does Denney’s conduct pose to the Association? Rather than focusing so much attention on the perceived problems created by a homeowner exercising his rights, the Board should be examining whether the President’s own conduct, judgment, and handling of disagreements are exposing the Association to unnecessary legal expense, conflict, and liability.

Homeowner Oversight Is Not the Problem

The Board is responsible for managing the Association, and homeowners are entitled to examine how that responsibility is being carried out. That includes requesting records, questioning decisions, identifying possible violations, and challenging actions they believe are inconsistent with the governing documents or applicable law.

The Board may disagree with my conclusions, defend its decisions, and explain the costs associated with managing the Association. But it should not portray legitimate homeowner oversight as misconduct or blame the homeowner for expenses resulting from the Board’s own decisions.

I am conducting independent oversight of the Association. That means examining the Board’s actions, asking difficult questions, and sometimes being critical. The Board may not appreciate that scrutiny, but it is part of accountability. Attempting to discredit the person conducting that oversight does nothing to answer the questions being raised. It only makes transparency and accountability more difficult.

What’s Next

The Board has issued its final determination, but I do not agree with its reasoning or its position on the records-access restrictions. I intend to submit another Notice of Final Adverse Decision (NFAD) to the Virginia Common Interest Community Ombudsman, asking for review of the Board’s decision.



In its Notice of Final Determination, the Board specifically noted that its new records access policy was drafted by the Association’s attorney. Why that detail was considered relevant to the Board’s determination is unclear.

An attorney’s involvement in drafting a policy does not establish that the policy complies with Virginia law. The Association previously relied on its legal position to withhold architectural applications, yet the Ombudsman determined that the Association’s refusal to provide those records violated Va. Code § 55.1-1815.

The relevant question is not who drafted the policy, but whether the restrictions it imposes are authorized by law.

Based on the time involved in my previous complaint, I expect the process could take another two to three months. When the Ombudsman’s decision is issued, I will report the outcome here.

To be continued.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments