Tom Denney Responds to Homeowner Complaints
At the first board meeting after the snowstorm last January, Board president Tom Denney addressed the numerous homeowner complaints about snow removal.


Glaring Omission
His response essentially boils down to the board giving the vendor a stern talking-to. That’s nice—but notice what he didn’t say. He never addressed the most common complaint raised by a large number of homeowners: the late start of snow removal on sidewalks and driveways. Under the contract, work was supposed to begin after the snow event ended, yet it didn’t actually start until nearly 12 hours later.
Board Ignores Contract Breach
On the surface, his response sounds reasonable. The Board “heard” the complaints, spoke with the contractor, and identified areas for improvement. Case closed, right?
Not exactly.
What’s missing from this response is the most important issue: the contract.
As outlined in a prior post, the vendor failed to meet clear contractual obligations. This wasn’t just a matter of “missing a few things” — it was a failure to perform under the terms the HOA is paying for. That’s not a communication issue. That’s a breach of contract.
And yet, there was no mention of it.
No acknowledgment that the vendor didn’t meet contractual standards.
No indication that the Board evaluated the situation through that lens.
And most importantly, no mention of whether the HOA pursued any credits or financial remedies on behalf of homeowners.
Instead, the focus was on having a conversation with the vendor and hoping for better results next time.
That raises a simple question:
If a vendor fails to deliver what they were contractually obligated to provide, and the Board doesn’t enforce the contract or seek compensation — who exactly are they advocating for?
It’s perfectly reasonable for the Board to address performance issues and expect improvement going forward. But that’s only half the job. The other half is holding vendors accountable when they don’t meet their obligations.
Because if the HOA isn’t enforcing its contracts, then what exactly are homeowners paying for?
Here’s what’s really ironic: the board engaged lawyers to try to prevent me from obtaining the snow removal contract, as I documented here, yet there’s no indication they’ve engaged counsel to determine whether that contract was actually breached. Make this make sense.
The board doesn’t seem to realize they have leverage over the vendor—and could use it to secure a monetary concession. That’s exactly what the board, as agents for the homeowners, should be doing.
The Complaints
For the record, here are some of the complaints from the community Facebook group. Many more complaints were submitted directly to the management company.
Misunderstanding of How Contracts Work
Just like the board, a few homeowners clearly don’t understand how contracts work. “Meta John” (John Topp) is a good example. He states “sidewalks and driveways are typically cleared after the storm has concluded”—which is precisely how the contract is written. The contract doesn’t say anything about “standard procedures being adjusted,” “reasonable effort,” or any kind of vague “pre-set expectations.” It sets specific obligations. Had “Meta John” bothered to request a copy of the snow removal contract, this would have been obvious. It’s not about what feels reasonable; it’s about what was actually agreed to.
What’s interesting about people who hold this position is that they almost certainly wouldn’t tolerate it in their own lives. If they hired a contractor for landscaping and the work didn’t meet the contract’s terms, they’d either have the contractor return until it was done right or demand a partial refund.


What Changed Between 2025 and 2026?
What changed between January 2025, when snow removal went smoothly during a similar storm, and January 2026? The answer: different vendors. January 2025 was handled by Greatscapes; January 2026 by Ruppert. Most likely, Ruppert was overbooked, while Greatscapes was not.
See Also: Related Posts on Tom Denney
Concerns About Transparency Under Board President Tom Denney – Board President Denney addressed homeowner concerns about transparency. This post looks at the gap between those assurances and how board decisions have actually been handled.

